Don't miss out! Get fresh, fun finance tips delivered daily.
26 Oct 2011

The Author

Julie Mayfield

Julie Mayfield is a freelance writer and blogger who writes about everything having to do with personal finance. She shares money saving and debt reduction tips on her blog, The Family CEO. When she’s not reading or writing about money, you can usually find her hanging out with her friends and family and cheering on the Kansas Jayhawks.

Read more of Julie's money-saving tips below or view her other work at TheFamilyCEOblog.com.

...if you like Julie's work, check out the blog posts from another personal finance guru who contributes to this publication: Jenny Kerr
How To Pay Cash for Cars and Why it’s a Good Idea
Pay Cash for Cars Why Good Idea

In our 25 years of marriage we’ve bought cars in almost every way imaginable: new from a dealer, used from a dealer, and used from an individual. We even leased a car (bad idea) and bought the car outright when we were done.

It’s fair to say we’re pretty experienced in the ways to buy cars.

But this week we bought a used car for my teenage son and we did something new. We saved up and paid cash for it. It was by far the most satisfying way to buy a car and we plan to do more of it.

Why Pay Cash When Buying a Car?

Paying cash for a car has several benefits. The most obvious is that you save the interest you will pay on the financing of a car. That, in itself, makes the car cheaper.

But that’s about finance. Another benefit of paying cash is more of a psychological one: you tend to spend less than you would if you were financing.

When you hand over cash for a car, you feel every extra dollar. The amount you have budgeted for the car becomes very real and it’s hard to let that number creep up.

That’s not the case when you finance a car, because you’re looking mostly at the monthly payment amount. And what’s an extra $10 or $25 or even $100 a month when you’re talking about a car payment? Especially if you’ve fallen in love with the car.

A lower purchase price will probably save you money in other ways too. Your sales tax, property tax, and even insurance rates are all tied to the value of your car. Those will be lower if you spend less.

How to Pay Cash for a Car

So let’s assume you’re sold on the benefits of paying cash. How do you go about saving for such a large purchase?

If you currently have a car with a payment, the solution may be easier that you think. Simply continue to save the car payment amount after the loan is paid off and plan to do it for the amount of time you financed the car in the first place.

If you can manage to do that, you will have saved the purchase price of a new (or used) car. Keep funneling that money away and you’ve just eliminated the bank, credit union, or car finance company from all of your future car buying. You’re paying yourself instead of paying them.

If you don’t currently have a car payment, you’ll need to find the money to begin saving for your next car today. Don’t make it more complicated than it needs to be. Do some rough calculations about when you want to buy your next car and how much you want to spend. Simple division will give you the amount you need to start setting aside each month.

The money will essentially come from one of two places:

  1. Money you carve out from your existing budget.
  2. Or money you earn on the side through part-time work or a business enterprise.

The key is planning, because if you don’t plan for your next car, you will certainly be financing it. And how will you find the money then?

How about you? Do you finance or pay cash for your cars? If you pay cash, what’s your system for saving?

Julie Mayfield is a freelance writer and blogger who writes about everything having to do with personal finance. She shares money saving and debt reduction tips on her blog, The Family CEO. When she’s not reading or writing about money, you can usually find her hanging out with her friends and family and cheering on the Kansas Jayhawks.

Photo: cjc4454

14 Comments
  • http://www.facebook.com/sunk818 Sun W Kim

    I take it the art of haggling with cash is not something you cover? That can bring down the price of the car. Is this something you recommend or not?

  • http://carefulcents.com Carrie Smith

    I would definitely recommend negotiating (aka haggling) too. Waving $16,000 cash in front of a small business owner of an used auto dealer is how I got such a fantastic deal on my first car. It never hurts to try!

  • joaotryssa

    Ive never bought a car in cash, so Im wondering….Do you actually take all that cash in hand with you and show it to the car salesman?? Or do you just show him a blank checK/debit card??

  • http://carefulcents.com Carrie Smith

    I told the dealer I was going to pay in cash. I paid for part of the balance by cashier’s check, and then brought over $10,000 cash (100 dollar bills) to the dealer. With all that money in front of him, he paid for the taxes, registration and all that. So it definitely helps to have that cash in hand. 

  • Alan Weisberg

    I have a few issues with this blog, and a couple of comments others have added.  First, negotiating for a cash deal does NOT work.  Most dealers work with several banks and make money (commission on the interest) when you finance through them…sometimes thousands of dollars.  Often this actually means they can offer you a better deal on the car when you finance, because they make more money on the “back end.”  Sell a new car for $300 profit, or make hundreds, maybe thousands more by having you finance?  If you think you got a better deal because you offered cash, you’ve likely been deceived.

    Also, if you are purchasing a new car and you have good to excellent credit, many manufacturers ofter very low rates…as low as 0%, 1.9% etc.  If you can get those rates, take them.  You can take your cash and earn better rates elsewhere, meaning you purchase your vehicle and make money at the same time.

    Lastly, this blogger states that leasing is a bad idea.  Possibly true when you lease the vehicle, and then purchase it at the end of the lease.  However, if you are the kind of buyer who likes and typically gets a new vehicle every three years or so, leasing is an excellent, lower cost choice.  You’ll spend far less in interest costs.  Also, you’ll typically spend only for routine maintenance as your car will usually be well covered by the manufacturer’s warranty.

    I hope this information is useful.
    ,

  • http://Twitter.com/KylePs80 Kyle Psaty

    Great points here, Alan. As with most things financial, there are almost always different ways to look at this topic. That’s part of what makes this stuff confusing.

    Positing new ideas and differing opinions in the comments is always encouraged here, so long as you’re respectful while doing it, which you clearly were. Sharing thoughts on financial topics isn’t always easy, so thank you for doing that as well. 

    By taking the time to weigh in and disagree, you are adding to the dialogue that makes this an informative, interesting place to hang out, whether you’re a PerkStreet customer or not. Thanks, Alan, for helping make this blog more useful. 

    -Kyle

    Kyle Psaty
    PerkStreet Financial

  • Guest

    More info on how to pay cash for cars and have them free for life… http://www.daveramsey.com/article/drive-free/

  • http://Twitter.com/KylePs80 Kyle Psaty

    WoWoWoW! That video was AWESOME. Reason number 5,212 why I love Dave Ramsey. Great addition to this conversation, Guest. Thanks much for adding it to the comments. 

    -Kyle

    Kyle Psaty
    PerkStreet Financial

  • http://www.facebook.com/elcamino73 Jeremy Fulton

    I HIGHLY reccomend haggling with cash!  If you show up to a private seller with cash, that is way more powerful than “i’ll apply for a loan and if i get it i’ll buy your car”.  Imagine if you were selling the car.  But don’t give up your walk away power, that can be powerful, too

  • http://www.facebook.com/elcamino73 Jeremy Fulton

    I’ve paid cash for my last 3 cars (granted one was only $150), but it is WAY more satisfying than having a ‘nicer’ car w/ payments.

  • contactat privatefleet

    Hi,

    Recently I came across some great articles on your site. The other day, I was discussing (http://dailyperk.perkstreet.com/how-to-pay-cash-for-cars-and-why-its-a-good-idea/ ) with my colleagues and they suggested I submit an article of my own.  Your site is just perfect for what I have written!  Would it be ok to submit the article?  It is free of charge, of course!

    Let me know what you think 
    Contact me at contactatprivatefleet@gmail.com

    Regards,
    Audrianna  Parker

  • RachelS

    While this was an excellent illustration of how our car choice can have a big impact on our lifestyle, I have a HUGE bone to pick with Dave Ramsey: 12% growth? Really?? Even after the past few years?!?!? Sorry, but all of those figures at the end there, including the $5.5 million decision, are vastly overstated.

    In our practice, we use 6.5-7% as an average rate, and that’s for clients who are willing to take moderate risks. You’d have $80,000 saved instead of $100k after 10 years, $233k instead of $470k in 20 years, $525k instead of $1.6m after 30 years, and $1,084,719 after 40 years instead of $5.5m. That’s quite a difference.

    Also, at a more reasonable 6.5-7%, you’d have enough to buy 4 $12,000 vehicles over 15 years, but you’d run out of money after buying the 4th vehicle.

    Just things to keep in mind!

  • Bigbrojwc

    if i buy a car and pay with cash will the car dealer pay my sales tax for me or will i still have to pay some on sales tax

  • kyle

    you should probably pay cash by using a cashier’s check. I certainly wouldn’t recommend carrying that much cash around a used car lot.

Account

The DailyPerk is here to help you find ways to live better for less.

Get a head start by grabbing a PerkStreet debit card with awesome cash back rewards!

Credit card style rewards for spending on debit? See, we’re helping already!